JAY-Z and Mary J. Blige famously said, “I’m taking out this time/To give you a piece of my mind/’Cause you can’t knock the hustle” on the 1996 Reasonable Doubt single “Can’t Knock The Hustle.” But apparently, that’s not the case when it comes to using JAY-Z’s likeness without his permission.
According to TMZ, JAY-Z is suing veteran Hip Hop photographer Jonathan Mannion and his company Jonathan Mannion Photography LLC for allegedly exploiting the Roc Nation mogul’s name and image without his consent. Court documents reportedly point out Mannion has photographs of JAY-Z all over his website and sells photos of Hov for thousands of dollars.
But JAY-Z says Mannion never had his permission to do so and claims when he asked Mannion to stop using the images, Mannion demanded millions of dollars. Jay believes Mannion is making an “arrogant assumption that because he took those photographs, he can do with them as he pleases.”
JAY-Z hired Mannion to shoot the cover art for Reasonable Doubt in 1996. He wound up taking hundreds of photos of the Brooklyn-bred legend for Roc-A-Fella Records and was paid “handsomely” for the snaps. But it seems that’s where Jay thought their working relationship was supposed to end.
“It’s ironic that a photographer would treat the image of a formerly-unknown Black teenager, now wildly successful, as a piece of property to be squeezed for every dollar it can produce,” the docs say. “It stops today.”
JAY-Z is suing Mannion in an effort to get him to stop selling the photographs and he also wants any of the profits Mannion has made off his likeness.
Hip Hop Photography Has Told The Culture’s History Decades Before Instagram - Just Ask These Lens Legends
On Mannion’s side, it’s been all love over the last two decades. Last December, he shared an undated photo of himself with JAY-Z and wrote in the caption, “SAG SEASON CONTINUES!Blessings and huge respect to the greatest to ever do it! It has been a true honor and privilege to create images with you over the years, Jay.”
HipHopDX has reached out to Mannion for comment.
Hov is such a lowlife swindler. He can’t let homie make a few G’s from some photos that he actually took in the 90’s? It ain’t easy to make bread as a photographer, and Jake-Z is a fucking billionaire. What a pathetic and greedy camel. Just let homie sell his photos. He probably has a family to feed.
It doesn’t matter how much money HOV has, he never gave home boy permission to use him for profit point blank.
Exactly. It’s not the money, it’s putting a stop to theft.
It takes two minutes to google this shyt. “The owner of the ‘work’ is generally the photographer or, in certain situations, the employer of the photographer. Even if a person hires a photographer to take pictures of a wedding, for example, the photographer will own the copyright in the photographs unless the copyright in the photographs is transferred, in writing and signed by the copyright owner, to another person. The subject of the photograph generally has nothing to do with the ownership of the copyright in the photograph.”
Theft? As the photographer, he likely owned the copyright and could do what he wanted with the pictures. Jay is scum for this.
When the billionaire trust fund babies so over bs, no problem, eh?
Can you make a few G’s off Walmarts likeness? HOV is actual business, he has to request the right to use Jay’s likeness. like a typical white dude he thought he was entitled to a black man’s image and likeness.
Once again…. lane Jayz making news like a reality pop star…. that album is the only reason hes anyone in hiphop… after that, dude is just a rapper who will do anything for money…somehow hes got stans… I don’t get it…. he sucks and has sucked since his mainstream jiggy days.
What have you accomplished?
By claiming ownership of his image? Jealousy & hatred will keep you a sad individual
oh its just another squabble.